- Under New York’s ethics rules, a lawyer can’t use or reveal what you share in a consultation, even if you never hire that lawyer.
- Confidential communications with a lawyer made to get legal advice are also generally protected by the attorney-client privilege.
- Bringing friends or family into the meeting, or repeating what you said to others, can put that protection at risk, so it helps to know the ground rules before you go.
There is nothing worse than being hurt because of a negligent individual. The Law Offices of Richard M. Kenny is a personal injury law firm dedicated to helping the wrongfully injured recover their rightful compensation. Read on and reach out to us to learn more about how you can prepare for your initial consultation with your Bronx personal injury lawyer. Our serious injury lawyers find that people often hold back in a first meeting because they aren’t sure who will hear what they say. Here’s what you should know.
Is what I tell a lawyer at a free consultation confidential?
Yes. Under Rule 1.18 of the New York Rules of Professional Conduct, a person who discusses with a lawyer the possibility of hiring them is a “prospective client,” and the lawyer generally can’t use or reveal information learned in that consultation, even if you never sign a retainer. That means you can be honest about the details that worry you, like a prior injury, a missed doctor’s appointment or something you said at the scene. Those are exactly the facts a lawyer needs to hear early.
Does the attorney-client privilege apply?
Generally, yes. Under CPLR 4503, confidential communications between a lawyer and client made in the course of professional employment are privileged, which means the other side generally can’t force them to be disclosed. The key word is confidential. If friends or relatives sit in on the meeting, or you later share the details of what your lawyer told you on social media or with the insurance company, the protection can be weakened or lost. An interpreter or someone you need to help you communicate is a different situation, so ask the lawyer how to handle it.
How can I prepare for my initial consultation with a personal injury lawyer?
Of course, the most important thing you should do after sustaining a serious injury in an accident is receive medical treatment at once. That being said, you should also do what you can to collect documentation to help support your claim and prepare for your initial consultation. Just some of the documentation you should bring to your initial consultation, if possible, is as follows:
- A copy of all medical documentation detailing the type of accident you were in, the injuries you sustained, the amount of time you missed from work, and the cost of medical treatment
- Any pictures or videos of your accident occurring
- Witness contact information
- A copy of the police report filed at the scene of the accident
- A list of questions you may have for your lawyer
- Any correspondence you may have had with the other party’s insurance company
- Your insurance info, including auto or health insurance
We understand that this may seem like a lot, and if you are unable to obtain all of the above, simply come with what you do have. Our guide to getting your records before a first meeting explains how to request them. Being prepared and bringing this information to our firm can help us understand your case faster.
How long will I have to speak with a personal injury attorney after an accident?
No one should ever wait to speak with a personal injury attorney after an accident. Once you’ve received medical treatment and are out of the hospital, you should speak with a competent personal injury attorney as soon as you can. There is a statute of limitations in place that regulates how long people have to bring personal injury claims, generally three years in New York, and claims involving the City or another public agency usually require a notice of claim within 90 days. Don’t miss these deadlines–simply reach out to an attorney as soon as possible.
Common Questions About Injury Consultations in NY
Should I record my consultation or bring a friend to take notes?
It’s usually better to ask the lawyer first. A third person in the room can affect confidentiality, and many firms will send you a written summary of next steps instead.
What if I decide not to hire the lawyer?
Your information is still protected. The lawyer generally can’t use or reveal what you shared in the consultation.
Speak With a New York City Injury Lawyer Today
To talk about what happened, call our office at (212) 421-0300 or request a free case evaluation online.





